Nehemiah Toles was ranked the top outfielder in Ohio and had Division-I college offers, including from Yale, along with interest from MLB scouts as he approached high school graduation. He turned it all down to pursue full-time Christian ministry instead.
“It’s the scariest thing to be gifted at something that God did not call you to… Baseball was my passion, it wasn’t my purpose,” Toles told Fox News Digital.
Toles now runs his own ministry, traveling across the country to preach the Gospel to young people. He grew up with a father who was a pastor transitioning into evangelism, but says he once viewed faith and churchgoing as “corny.”
He has said he used baseball as a “coping mechanism” while struggling with anxiety and depression that intensified during the 2020 pandemic.
“From 13 years old to 16 years old… I felt like I struggled to connect with people, struggled to just articulate my thoughts. And so… I went back to church, [and] before I even started worshiping or anything like that, I felt the presence of God just hit me. All my anxiety, all my depression left, and I had tried everything else and nothing else was working,” Toles said.
A Home Run, Then a Decision
Toles described the moment the offers started pouring in, during a championship game while he was ranked the state’s top outfielder. As he rounded the bases on a home run, his coach was on the phone fielding calls from recruiters.
“I’m in the dugout. And [my coach] he’s like… before [you] touched home plate, three Division-I coaches had just confirmed,” Toles said.
He recalled his parents’ joy and his father’s tears at the news of offers from Yale and other schools. But that same night, alone in a hotel room, he said he heard God ask him a pointed question.
“[In] the hotel room that night and I felt like the Lord had spoke[n] to me, like, ‘Is that enough? Was that what you were looking for? Like, is this ever, is it going to be enough?'”
Soon after, while volunteering at a community event for children in need, Toles said he felt torn between two paths — and found the work with the kids more fulfilling than baseball success.
“I felt like God was calling me into full-time ministry and so… [During that] exact event, I went back to the green room and I called half of the Division-I coaches and told them I’m not going to come to their college, I’m going full-time into ministry,” Toles said.
Pushback From Family and Coaches
The decision strained relationships with his family and prompted hard conversations with guidance counselors, coaches and other adults urging him to reconsider.
“Everything that the world had offered me didn’t satisfy me… I remember feeling so deceived and feeling so frustrated, because doing the things that people had told me to do [that] they said they would make me happy and would fulfill me… didn’t,” he said.
Toles said that even amid the pressure and self-doubt, he received clarity.
“He made it so evident to me, He [said], obedience to me will always be insanity to the world.”
Toles now devotes his time to his ministry, traveling the country to preach to young people.




