A federal appeals court has ruled against the Trump administration in a dispute over New York’s commercial driver’s licenses and nearly $74 million in federal highway money.
A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last week that New York does not have to retroactively apply new federal regulations governing commercial driver’s licenses, or CDLs, issued to migrants whose legal residency has since ended.
Earlier this year, the Trump administration changed federal rules to require states to tie the validity of a CDL to a migrant’s legal residency status, so that the license would expire when legal status does. The change followed findings that thousands of migrants held valid commercial licenses even after losing legal residency, allowing them to keep working as commercial drivers without lawful status.
The Department of Homeland Security and Department of Transportation told New York and other states to cancel the CDLs of these drivers to come into compliance with the new rule. New York declined and sued instead, arguing the new requirement could not be applied to licenses issued before the rule existed.
In response, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration withheld four percent of New York’s federal-aid highway funding for fiscal year 2027 — close to $74 million, according to Newsweek.
The appeals panel sided with New York, writing that “the agency could not withhold federal funding based on a state’s noncompliance with a regulatory requirement that did not exist.”
The panel included two appointees of President Biden, Judges Alison J. Nathan and Sarah A. L. Merriam, and one appointee of President Trump, Judge Matthew A. Schwartz. Judge Schwartz joined the majority, saying the case had to be decided according to the rules in place at the time, which did not address legal residency expiration dates.
The administration had argued the residency requirement was effectively already implied under existing law, since migrants cannot legally work once their status ends. The court rejected that argument and held that New York cannot be penalized retroactively for not following a standard that did not yet exist in regulation.
The ruling applies only to the funding dispute. A separate lawsuit challenging the underlying rule — which ties CDL validity to a migrant’s legal residency date — remains pending in the courts.




