Biden’s New Memoir Explains the ‘We Beat Medicare’ Debate Line

Biden's New Memoir Explains the 'We Beat Medicare' Debate Line

Former President Joe Biden has addressed the “we beat Medicare” moment from his disastrous June 2024 debate against Donald Trump in his new memoir, “Promise Me, America,” released Tuesday.

Biden wrote that he meant to highlight a major accomplishment of his administration but instead botched the line under pressure. “As I was finishing an answer on the deficit, I lost my train of thought, saw that my time was running out on the clock, and rushed the final part of my answer by blurting out: ‘We finally beat Medicare.’ What I meant to say was, ‘We finally beat Big Pharma,'” he wrote.

He explained he was referring to the Inflation Reduction Act, which gave Medicare the power to negotiate lower drug prices. “This had been a huge accomplishment in my administration,” he wrote. “Ironically, this historic achievement wouldn’t lift my candidacy. It would help to sink it. What should have been a highlight of the debate became Exhibit A that I was too old to do the job.”

Biden Says Trump Lied, But His Own Performance Dominated Coverage

Biden accused Trump of lying repeatedly during the debate but said that didn’t matter in the end. “Yet none of what he said would generate any impression that lasted past debate night,” he wrote. “It would be my answers and my performance that would dominate the press coverage and political conversation in the weeks ahead.”

He said he initially believed he could recover. “I knew the debate had gone badly. But I knew that debates had gone badly for lots of incumbent presidents,” he wrote. “I left the stage thinking I would be debating Trump once more before the election was over.”

Biden argued that polling immediately after the debate showed the race tightening, not collapsing. “It would take weeks of hammering in the press before the polls started to move downward,” he wrote, comparing his numbers to Barack Obama’s five-point drop after his first debate against Mitt Romney in 2012. “But the data wasn’t the point. The narrative was. And the narrative was bad.”

Comparing Himself to Past Presidents

Biden pointed to a history of incumbent presidents stumbling in their first debates. He recalled Ronald Reagan appearing “lost and confused” against Walter Mondale, George W. Bush being caught with a “scowling face,” and Obama looking like he “didn’t care if he won or lost” against Romney.

“There’s a reason most incumbent presidents have a bad first debate: They’re more focused on the country’s and the world’s problems than on campaigning,” Biden wrote. “The difference in 2024 was not that I had a bad debate. Lots of presidents had bad debates. The difference was that every other president was given the chance to redeem themselves in a second debate. As it turned out, that chance would not be available to me.”

In an interview with People magazine about the memoir, Biden downplayed the significance of the moment. “Look, I don’t know anybody who hasn’t made a mistake in a debate,” he said. “To me, it was not very consequential. First of all, I thought there’d be another debate, which there wasn’t.”

Jill Biden’s Account, and a Scholar’s Take

Former first lady Jill Biden said in a CBS News “Sunday Morning” interview in May that she thought her husband was having a stroke on stage during the debate.

The debate preceded weeks of pressure from fellow Democrats that ultimately led Biden to drop out of the 2024 race.

Costas Panagopoulos, a professor of political science at Northeastern University, told Fox News Digital that Biden’s broader point has merit but misses the core issue.

“Biden is correct. He was not the only president to have a bad debate performance. Previous candidates did have an opportunity to recover. The problem for Biden was not simply that he had a bad debate but rather that his poor performance reinforced a prevalent narrative that he was ill-equipped to run the country given his advanced age,” Panagopoulos said.

He added that concerns about Biden’s age existed on both sides of the political aisle well before the debate. “The debate just put the final nail into the coffin,” he said.

Author picture

Leave a Replay

Recent Posts

Sign up for Joe's Newsletter, The Daily Informant