Mayor Zohran Mamdani this week named 10 new judges to New York City’s criminal and family courts and reappointed six sitting judges, a list that includes a Manhattan Criminal Court judge known among law enforcement officials as “Judge Let-em-Go.”
That judge, Valentina Morales, is a former public defender in Harlem who was first appointed to the bench by then-Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2021. Between January and June 2024, Morales released 83 of the 101 alleged violent felons who appeared before her without bail, including Eric Taylor, a repeat offender previously convicted on two felony charges and nearly two dozen misdemeanors.
While serving as a Bronx judge in 2022, Morales released Frankie Centeno on electronic monitoring for gun possession charges, despite the Bronx District Attorney’s request for $100,000 cash bail or a $300,000 bond. Centeno later fled the country and had to be rearrested.
Morales also released Venezuelan migrant Walter Almachi Leal without bail after he allegedly slashed a 43-year-old victim with a broken beer bottle in 2023, and freed Kalifa Quattara, an 18-year-old member of the “Up the Hill” gang, on electronic monitoring last year following a shootout with rival gang members.
Morales is not the only reappointed judge whose record has drawn scrutiny. Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid attorney who joined the bench last year, declined in August to hold career criminal Shaquan Seth without bail despite prosecutors’ requests, even though Seth had nearly 150 prior arrests. Saint-Preux instead set a $10,000 bond.
Other reappointments include Acting Queens Supreme Court Justice Toni Cimino, a former criminal defense lawyer who became a judge in 2016; Judge Tamiko Amaker, deputy chief administrative judge in criminal court, appointed by de Blasio in 2017; Bronx Criminal Court Judge Joseph Sorrentino, a former chief appellate court attorney who joined the bench in 2024; and Bronx Family Court Judge Juanita Wing, who began her career at the state Administration for Children’s Services before her 2024 appointment.
New Appointments
According to the mayor’s office, at least six of the 10 new judges being appointed to city criminal and family courts are current or former public defenders.
The new criminal court nominees include former Legal Aid lawyers Alexis Flyer and Molly Gallivan, along with William Kendall, a former supervising attorney at Neighborhood Defender Services in Harlem. Two other criminal court nominees, Hana Kim and Melissa Medilien, previously worked as prosecutors in the Queens District Attorney’s Office.
Among the five family court appointees, Mary Cheng and Beth Krause both have Legal Aid backgrounds, with Cheng having worked in Maryland. Brian Holbrook is senior attorney for law and appeals at Brooklyn Defender Services. Deana Tietjen is deputy director at the Children’s Law Center and previously served as a legal awareness adviser in Westchester County, while Danielle Rodriguez most recently worked as a court attorney referee in Queens.
City Hall said all nominees were vetted by the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary and will be the subject of a public hearing Tuesday.
“The decision made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life,” Mamdani said in a statement. “That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work.”




