Stephen A. Smith Defends His Approach After Trump Interview Draws Fact-Check Criticism

Stephen A. Smith Defends His Approach After Trump Interview Draws Fact-Check Criticism

ESPN host Stephen A. Smith is defending how he handled his recent White House interview with President Donald Trump, after critics argued he should have challenged the president’s statements in real time.

Smith said Tuesday that while his interview was generally well received, some people “who have been in this industry before” criticized him for not pushing back harder during the conversation. His response: doing so would have ended the interview before it got anywhere.

“You don’t walk into the White House and talk to the president of the United States and plan on fact-checking him on the spot or interrupting him every sentence that he utters out of his mouth,” Smith said. “You know why? Because you won’t get through the damn interview. That’s why.”

Smith pointed to Trump’s tendency to “filibuster,” wander off topic and exaggerate during interviews, saying that correcting every such moment in the room either eats up time or risks the president cutting the interview short.

“I wanted to be able to challenge and push back in certain respects, but in the same breath, keep him in the damn chair because he does have the potential to just get up and walk off as he has done to people before,” Smith said.

Smith said he’s not opposed to pushing back on interview subjects, including the president, but believes interviewers need to be selective about when to do it.

“The goal, at least for me, is not to fact-check them on the spot in most instances,” Smith said. “It’s to make sure that they’re quoted for the record, so we always have them on the record about what their positions are. That way, when we go back to double- and triple-check the facts, we’re able to say, ‘Hey, that wasn’t true.'”

He went on to fact-check several of Trump’s statements later in the same video and called on people across the political spectrum to “stop the BS.”

“Ladies and gentlemen, this is chess, it ain’t checkers. And if every politician had to get fact-checked in real time, you wouldn’t get interviews. I can give you plenty of Democrats that don’t want to show up and get fact-checked. And Republicans, for that matter. Let’s not act like we don’t know any better,” Smith said.

Fox News Digital said it reached out to Smith’s representatives and the White House for comment.

Smith, who has criticized both major parties in the past, has previously defended his decision to sit down with Trump despite disagreeing with his politics. Last month on “The View,” he said:

“There are so many people that have this mentality, ‘Why even waste time talking to him?’ Whether you like him or not, he’s the president of the United States of America. He’s not going away until 2028. At least. He’s not going away,” Smith said.

Curtis Houck, managing editor of Newsbusters, told Fox News Digital that interviewing high-profile figures like the president requires a “balancing act.”

“A constant state of antagonistic fact-checks or baboonish hectoring can derail an interview and prevent it from creating headlines other than its combative nature. As much as liberal, elitist journalists claim otherwise, so many love being the headline. With this President, he can often make headlines in sit-downs when he’s allowed time to speak. There is absolutely merit to what Stephen A. Smith said,” Houck said.

Author picture

Leave a Replay

Recent Posts

Sign up for Joe's Newsletter, The Daily Informant