Ed O’Neill’s long-ago tryout with the Pittsburgh Steelers turned into a story that mixes near-miss football dreams, a blackout night out, and a hometown that treats its potential pros like family.
Before he was known for his TV roles, Ed O’Neill was fighting for a roster spot with the Steelers, undrafted and up against established names like Joe Greene, and he remembers the coaches reading his playbook on a day forever linked to the moon landing. He has recounted this episode on Julian Edelman’s Names with Games podcast in 2024, and the tale still lands because it pairs the absurdity of one night with the stubborn loyalty of a football town. The tryout itself was a long shot from the start, and the way the story unfolded speaks more about the culture than the cut.
After the practice news landed, O’Neill says he found himself at a bar where the moon landing flickered on a screen and the room felt electric; he remembers thinking, “Well, someone had a good day.” That thought stuck because the patrons quickly recognized him as a player who’d been released that day and decided to buy him drinks, and the scene escalated in classic late-night fashion. By the end of the evening he was, as he puts it, half-naked in a car with a woman and then stopped by the police, which made the whole episode feel like a bizarre detour from trying to make a team roster.
He was so drunk he could not recall his own name, yet he managed to hand over his driver’s license to the officer, who then realized who he was and asked whether he had been cut by the team that day. The exchange didn’t turn hostile; instead, it read almost like a check-in from a town that keeps tabs on its own, with the officer later checking with the woman in the car about whether she could take O’Neill home. The memory of that night stuck with him precisely because the reaction from strangers was unexpectedly protective rather than dismissive.
O’Neill summed up the sentiment he encountered in simple terms, and his reflection captures why this anecdote still resonates. “It was Pittsburgh,” said O’Neill. “Even if you got cut, it doesn’t make any difference,” he added. Those lines underline the way local fans treat players as part of a larger community, not just as temporary hires or drop-ins.
https://x.com/NicholeDelly/status/2090622900457865417
Julian Edelman, hosting the episode where O’Neill told the story, echoed that same idea and pointed to the embedded loyalty that defines Pittsburgh’s relationship with the Steelers. “They love them Steelers,” added Edelman. “You’re still part of the team” — the comment highlights how a single night, even a messy one, won’t erase the bond between player and city. That attitude explains why a cut player can still be welcomed, cheered, and even looked after on the streets of town.
Years later, the memory of being cut by Chuck Knoll found its way into O’Neill’s dreams, returning as a recurring image for decades and showing how a narrow career turn can linger in a person’s mind. The whole episode reads like a snapshot of a different era in both football and nightlife, where a single headline—on the same day the entire world was watching the moon landing—could collide with the very local drama of a roster decision. It’s a story that survived telling because it’s part self-deprecating comedy, part hometown loyalty, and part proof that sometimes the people in the stands treat you like family even when you don’t make the team.
