Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Monday announced his first slate of judicial appointments to New York City’s Criminal Court, naming five new judges to the bench. Three of the five have backgrounds as career public defenders, while only two have significant experience as prosecutors.
The mayor also named at least three Family Court picks with strong backgrounds in public defense work, often associated with organizations like Legal Aid. Among six judges reappointed to the bench, three also began their legal careers as defense attorneys.
One of those reappointed is Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales, who has drawn attention for a high release rate among defendants arraigned on violent felony charges — 82% during the first six months of 2024, according to figures cited by critics of her record.
Also reappointed was Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid attorney. In August, prosecutors sought to have Saint-Preux order the detention of Shaquan Seth, a defendant with a record of nearly 150 prior arrests. Saint-Preux instead set bond at $100,000 rather than ordering him held without bail.
Monday’s announcements mark the first round of judicial selections made entirely under Mamdani’s administration, following a dozen earlier appointments that had already been vetted under the previous mayor, Eric Adams.
Long-Term Impact on the Bench
The appointments carry significant weight because Criminal Court judges serve 10-year terms. The court includes 107 judgeships citywide. Civil Court judges, who are elected rather than mayorally appointed, are also sometimes assigned to Criminal Court duty.
Critics, including an opinion piece published by the New York Post, argue that judges with public defense backgrounds are less likely to set bail for defendants and more likely to seek alternatives to incarceration for those convicted of crimes. The Post opinion piece contends this approach will result in more repeat offenders remaining free, particularly as the city has not expanded its police force and anticipates reduced jail capacity under the city’s ongoing plan to close Rikers Island and replace it with smaller borough-based facilities.
Mamdani’s office has not issued a public response addressing the criticism of the judicial selections as of this report.




