A Fox News opinion column argues that President Trump has an opportunity to strike an immigration compromise that succeeds where President Ronald Reagan’s 1986 law failed, by making enforcement permanent before offering any legal relief to immigrants without legal status.
The piece, written by Mehek Cooke, contrasts what it calls two false extremes in the current debate: deporting everyone in the country illegally or granting blanket amnesty. It argues Washington’s unwillingness to move past this binary has stalled real reform for decades.
The column notes that Trump has opened negotiations with Democrats while ruling out blanket amnesty, favoring removal of people convicted of crimes such as murder, rape and drug dealing, while allowing individualized review for long-term residents with clean records and American family ties.
Democrats, according to the piece, have countered with the Protect Our Neighbors Act, which would let final removal orders expire after 10 years and create a pathway to permanent residency for certain immigrants without legal status. The column argues this rewards people for evading enforcement long enough to qualify for status.
Looking back at 1986
The article revisits Reagan’s 1986 immigration law, which granted legal status to nearly 2.7 million people while creating employer sanctions and border funding. It cites a Government Accountability Office finding that 39% of unauthorized workers identified in five major cities used or were suspected of using fraudulent documents, and that investigators often could not prove employers knew the documents were fake.
By the 1990s, a Congressional Research Service analysis found the unauthorized population had grown beyond its pre-1986 level, which the column attributes to legalization not being tied to lasting enforcement. It also cites GAO findings of unfilled border agent positions, reduced patrol time and failing equipment despite increased funding.
The current enforcement record
The piece credits Trump’s current term with a sharp drop in illegal crossings, saying southwest border apprehensions in fiscal year 2026 fell roughly 95% below the annual average during the Biden administration, and that Border Patrol completed its first fiscal year with zero releases into the United States.
Based on that record, the column calls on Congress to codify Trump’s border policies into law, mandate nationwide use of E-Verify, impose stiffer penalties on employers who knowingly hire workers without legal status, and limit future presidents’ ability to undo these measures unilaterally.
It proposes that any future immigration deal include specific benchmarks before legal relief expands: publicly reported removal numbers, zero Border Patrol releases, and a fully operational nationwide employment-verification system maintained for at least a year.
Case-by-case relief, not amnesty
The column argues that rejecting blanket amnesty doesn’t mean treating every immigrant without legal status the same way. It draws a distinction between someone with cartel ties and a parent who has been in the country 15 years, paid taxes, raised American children and has no criminal record, while stressing that good behavior




