A mother and daughter who worked at Ohio’s unemployment agency were convicted for approving ineligible Pandemic Unemployment Assistance payments, stealing roughly $1.94 million in public benefits and receiving multi-year prison terms and ordered restitution.
Authorities say Velma Cain and her daughter, Rashanna Burley, abused their positions at the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services during the COVID-19 surge in claims, approving payments to people who didn’t qualify. Investigators traced the improper actions to specific PUA transactions and tied those releases to the two employees. The case exposed glaring weaknesses in controls when the system was overwhelmed by pandemic-era demands.
The records show the fraudulent releases totaled $1,582,251 tied to Cain and $355,382 tied to Burley. Those figures come straight from the investigative findings and the court’s restitution order. The combined loss of roughly $1.94 million represents direct payouts intended for legitimately unemployed Ohioans during the pandemic.
In 2020, Congress created the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance program and loosened eligibility to get money quickly into the hands of those who lost work. That expansion, paired with millions of new claims, left state systems stretched and forced ODJFS to bring on intermittent and temporary contracted workers to process the volume. The staffing changes and rapid onboarding created new opportunities for abuse in an environment designed for speed rather than strict gatekeeping.
As a Customer Service Representative, Burley had responsibilities to review assigned PUA claims and verify required documents before payment. Investigators say she improperly accessed unassigned claims, removed holds and blocks, and authorized payments she was not allowed to release. Their analysis later showed Velma Cain, a former CSR and Burley’s mother, had also accessed and taken unauthorized actions on many of the same claims.
Ohio’s review of the pandemic response revealed the scale of the problem: in fiscal year 2021 ODJFS disbursed approximately $7.6 billion in pandemic unemployment benefits and later identified millions of dollars in fraudulent disbursals. To pursue accountability, an investigative team was formed that included the Office of the Ohio Inspector General, Ohio State Highway Patrol, United States Department of Labor – Office of Inspector General, and ODJFS. That multi-agency probe pulled together employment records, claim logs and system access histories to reconstruct how the payments moved through the agency.
On April 24, 2026, a Franklin County judge handed down prison sentences with a minimum period of incarceration of four years and a maximum of six years, consecutive to nine additional months on a different count. The court also ordered the defendants to pay restitution in the amounts of $1,582,251 and $355,382, respectively. Those penalties reflect both the dollar amounts taken and the seriousness of public-employee abuse of trust during an emergency.
The probe’s timeline included an official referral: on January 13, 2023, ODJFS referred an allegation of wrongdoing involving former intermittent Customer Service Representative Rashanna Burley to the Office of the Ohio Inspector General. That referral kicked off the deeper review that connected system activity to payments and tied those actions to specific user accounts. From there, auditors traced a pattern of unauthorized access that implicated both Burley and Cain.
Beyond the jail time and restitution, the case raises questions about how benefits systems balance speed and security under crisis conditions. Temporary hires and lighter eligibility checks solved an immediate need, but they also left gaping holes for fraudsters or dishonest insiders to exploit. State agencies and oversight bodies now face pressure to tighten controls without recreating the bottlenecks that slow aid to people who genuinely need it.
The legal result is straightforward: convictions, multi-year sentences and restitution orders for the two women found responsible for approving thousands in ineligible PUA payments. Prosecutors and investigators say the outcome should remind public employees that improper access and unauthorized actions have real consequences. The files and court rulings in this case will likely be referenced in future audits and policy debates about how to protect emergency programs from internal abuse.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy Townhall’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical Left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join Townhall VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
