A federal appeals court has declared Florida’s long-standing ban on concealed carry for 18- to 20-year-olds unconstitutional, a decision grounded in recent Supreme Court rulings and a clear reading of the Second Amendment.
The Fourth District Court of Appeal in Broward County made a unanimous ruling that struck down Florida’s 1987 law barring 18- to 20-year-olds from carrying concealed firearms. The judges relied on recent Supreme Court decisions that reshaped how courts evaluate gun regulations, and the opinion underscored a mismatch between military responsibilities given to young adults and restrictions on their self-defense rights. This outcome restores constitutional clarity for young Floridians and pushes back against age-based second-class status when it comes to bearing arms.
Across the country, the Supreme Court has been tightening the standard for restrictions on gun ownership and carry, forcing lower courts to reexamine older statutes. That legal shift made Florida’s ban vulnerable, since the law imposed special limits on a demographic that can serve in the armed forces and faces the same criminal penalties as older adults. For conservatives who prioritize constitutional protections, the ruling represents the sort of corrective action expected when courts apply the Second Amendment as written.
Three judges from the Fourth District Court of Appeal in Broward County unanimously ruled against the law, which was passed in 1987 and barred 18- to 20-year-olds from carrying concealed weapons.
Citing recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions that have dramatically reshaped the nation’s gun laws, Judge Spencer D. Levine wrote that the Florida statute “was contrary to our historical tradition and violates the Second Amendment.” He wrote that 18-year-olds are encouraged to join the military and “defend the country without restriction,” yet the law imposed “severe restrictions” on their right to self-defense.
The ruling was not unexpected. Mr. Uthmeier, a Republican who has championed gun rights, previously asked the court to strike down the law. On Wednesday, he said on social media that the decision was “another win for the unalienable rights of Floridians” to carry firearms.
Under Gov. Ron DeSantis, a two-term Republican, lawmakers and court rulings have made it easier to carry guns in Florida.
In 2023, Mr. DeSantis signed a law that eliminated the requirement for a permit to carry a concealed weapon.
[…]
In the case decided on Wednesday, a man who was 18 when he was arrested in 2024 on charges of carrying a concealed weapon in Broward County challenged the law.
The court’s opinion noted the practical and moral inconsistency of allowing 18-year-olds to enlist, be deployed, and face life-or-death decisions for their country while denying them the full rights of self-defense at home. That line of reasoning resonated with judges who are applying the Court’s evolving precedent on historical tradition and individual rights. For many Republicans and constitutionalists, the decision affirmed the idea that rights cannot be curtailed based on an arbitrary age threshold when responsibilities and expectations place young adults on equal footing with older citizens.
Florida’s legal landscape on firearms has been trending toward broader carry access in recent years, and the appeals court ruling fits into that pattern. The state eliminated the permit requirement for concealed carry in 2023, and the executive and legislative branches have moved to expand lawful self-defense options. Those policy choices reflect a conservative view that law-abiding citizens should be trusted with the means to protect themselves without excessive government gatekeeping.
Separately, the Florida House has been pushing to revisit a different age-based rule that dates to a post-Parkland legislative package. After the 2017 Parkland shooting, lawmakers raised the minimum age for certain handgun purchases to 21, while rifles and shotguns remained available to those 18 and older. That 2018 change, signed into law by the governor at the time, was controversial and described by some as a regrettable overreach that cut across Second Amendment principles.
Removing the carry ban for young adults is an important first step toward aligning state law with constitutional protections recognized by higher courts. This ruling clears a legal obstacle for 18- to 20-year-olds who have long argued that they should not be treated as less capable of self-defense. It also signals that other age-based restrictions may face renewed scrutiny if they cannot withstand the stricter tests now applied by appellate and supreme courts.
Republican leadership in Florida has consistently defended expanding lawful carry and protecting the right to self-defense, and this decision will be viewed as validation of those policy priorities. Courts and lawmakers alike will now have to reckon with the practical realities and constitutional limits around age-based firearm restrictions. The debate over how to balance public safety with individual rights will continue, but this ruling clearly shifts the legal baseline back toward the text and history of the Second Amendment.
Editor’s Note: President Trump and Republicans across the country are doing everything they can to protect our Second Amendment rights and right to self-defense.
