NPR, PBS, and Voice of America face defunding, reform due to perceived reporting bias concerns

National Public Radio, Public Broadcasting Service, and Voice of America are under scrutiny for perceived left-wing bias, prompting discussions about their funding. These broadcasting services, which benefit from public money, are accused of delivering slanted content. Critics, including politicians and former industry insiders, argue that NPR, PBS, and VOA push propaganda funded by taxpayers.

On Inauguration Day, PBS News posted a video on X featuring Tesla CEO Elon Musk, which stirred controversy. The clip was captioned, *“Billionaire Elon Musk gave what appeared to be a fascist salute Monday while making a speech at the post-inauguration celebration for President Donald Trump at the Capital One Arena.”*

Musk’s gesture, which followed his comments about the election’s significance, was compared by some to a Nazi salute. The Anti-Defamation League responded, emphasizing the tense political climate and suggesting that Musk’s actions were misinterpreted. They called for understanding and urged people to seek unity.

Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, a Republican from Georgia, shared the PBS post on X, expressing her intent to question PBS in her committee about their alleged bias. She criticized the use of taxpayer money to spread what she described as Democratic propaganda.

On January 21, Senator Mike Lee from Utah also took to X, advocating for the defunding of PBS and NPR, asserting that Americans should not be compelled to fund what he views as leftist media.

PBS has faced long-standing allegations of biased reporting. Michael Pack, the president of Manifold Productions, shared his experience with PBS regarding his documentary on the Iraq War. Despite being funded by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, PBS declined to air his film, claiming it was “too pro-military.”

Pack, who previously served as CEO of the U.S. Agency for Global Media, expressed his surprise at PBS’s decision, as his documentary merely depicted battles from the soldiers’ perspective.

Amid the calls to defund PBS and NPR, it’s crucial to understand that not all public broadcasting is directly funded by the federal government. Stations purchase content from these networks using federal funds, but they aren’t wholly government-funded.

NPR has also come under fire for its coverage. Last April, senior editor Uri Berliner resigned after being suspended for criticizing NPR’s perceived liberal bias. In an essay, Berliner condemned NPR’s handling of the Hunter Biden laptop story and its reluctance to cover it, suggesting that the network ignored a potentially significant news story due to political leanings.

The essay reignited broader concerns about NPR, including criticism of CEO Katherine Maher. Maher’s social media posts, which described former President Trump in negative terms, have fueled further scrutiny. Trump himself has called for defunding NPR, describing it as a “liberal disinformation machine” and urging that it receive no more funding.

In Congress, a bill aiming to defund NPR was introduced but failed to advance. NPR did not respond to requests for comment regarding the criticisms.

Voice of America has also faced allegations of bias. Following a violent incident involving Hamas and Israel in October 2023, VOA reportedly advised staff to use neutral terms when describing Hamas, despite its classification as a terrorist organization by the U.S. government. This guidance raised questions about VOA’s objectivity.

A VOA spokesperson emphasized the organization’s commitment to neutrality and fairness, asserting that journalists were reminded of these values in their reporting. They also noted that reports should acknowledge the U.S. government’s designation of Hamas as a terrorist group.

Historically, VOA has encountered similar issues. During Trump’s presidency, VOA employees posted content on social media that was critical of him, leading to accusations of bias.

Former VOA Director Robert Reilly criticized the organization’s Ukrainian service for sharing a politically charged video, adding to the ongoing debate about VOA’s impartiality.

Picture of Joe Messina

Joe Messina

All is fair in Radio! Politics, religion, prejudice, illegal immigration, legal immigration. Don't miss the "You're Not Serious" segment. We will be dealing with some of the most asinine items from the week's news. REAL and RAW!! You don't want to miss this show! The Real Side with Joe Messina. EVERY DAY - Check JoeMessina.com for stations and times.

Leave a Replay

Recent Posts

Sign up for Joe's Newsletter, The Daily Informant